HomeAccount ReceivableDealing with Short Pay? Here's How You Can Solve It

Dealing with Short Pay? Here’s How You Can Solve It

Short pay can cause a number of pain points for businesses, including cash flow disruptions, strained customer relationships, and administrative burdens associated with resolving the issue. In some cases, short pay can also lead to increased credit risk and potential financial losses.

However, by effectively managing short pay, businesses can mitigate these pain points and maintain healthy relationships with their customers.

This article will provide practical tips on how to handle short pay, including communicating with customers, negotiating a resolution, and issuing credit notes or invoice adjustments.

By following these guidelines, businesses can minimize the impact of short pay on their operations and financial management.

What Is a Short Pay

Short pay is a partial payment made by a customer or client. The amount paid is less than the amount due on the invoice. This situation may arise due to various factors, including disagreements regarding product or service quality, confusion surrounding pricing or contractual terms, or the unauthorized deduction of a discount or credit by the customer.

When short pay occurs, it is important for the supplier or vendor to take action to resolve the issue. This may involve communicating with the customer to understand the reason for the short pay and negotiating a resolution. In some cases, the supplier may need to issue a credit note or invoice adjustment to reflect the lower amount received.

Why Do Businesses Short Pay Invoices?

Common causes for short-paying invoices by businesses include:

  • Substandard quality: The business might feel the delivered goods or services did not meet the expected quality standards or adhere to the agreed-upon specifications.
  • Monetary disagreements: The business could dispute the invoiced amount due to confusion or discord over pricing, terms, or conditions.
  • Contractual complications: The business may perceive that the supplier failed to meet their contractual responsibilities, such as not delivering on time.
  • Fiscal challenges: The business might face financial strain or cash flow problems, leading to short-payment of invoices as a temporary measure.

To effectively address short-payment situations, it is crucial for businesses to approach the matter professionally and promptly. This approach helps maintain supplier relationships, prevent disputes from intensifying, and ensures the continued provision of required goods and services in the future.

When Is Doing Short Pay Considered Invalid?

Some examples of invalid reasons for short-paying invoices include:

  • Third-party payment delays or disagreements: Customers might short-pay invoices if they are awaiting payment from third parties or are contesting payments with them. Nevertheless, it is not a justifiable reason to short-pay an invoice when the business has met their obligations.

  • Administrative errors: Short-paying invoices due to administrative errors, such as typos or mistakes on the invoice, is not a valid reason. Instead, businesses should contact the supplier to resolve the issue and request a corrected invoice.
  • Cash flow management: Short-paying invoices for cash flow management reasons, such as delaying payment to suppliers to conserve cash, is not acceptable. It is important to maintain timely payments to suppliers to maintain positive relationships and avoid potential legal disputes.
  • Disliking the supplier: Short-paying invoices due to personal or emotional reasons, such as disliking the supplier or their salesperson, can harm business relationships and impact the quality of goods or services received.

The Business Impact Impact of Short Pays

The business impact of short pay can be detrimental to a company’s financial health and operational efficiency.

When customers remit payments that fall short of the invoiced amount, known as short pays, it frequently stems from disagreements, inconsistencies, or deductions related to invoicing. This increases the administrative burden, as businesses must monitor and resolve such matters to reclaim the unpaid funds, which can be both laborious and resource-demanding.

Short pay can adversely impact a company’s cash flow and operational capital, as collecting the outstanding amounts might take longer or potentially never occur. Consequently, this can put stress on the relationships between businesses and their customers, ultimately influencing customer satisfaction and loyalty.

By implementing effective strategies for managing short pay, such as investing in technology to automate invoice processing and streamlining dispute resolution processes, businesses can mitigate the negative consequences and maintain healthy cash flows.

How to Resolve Short Payments

Resolving short pays effectively requires a proactive approach and clear communication with customers.

In tackling a short pay scenario, the initial step is to pinpoint the source of the discrepancy. This process might entail examining the invoice and relevant supplementary documents, such as purchase orders or contracts, to identify any mistakes, discrepancies, or deductions that might have prompted the customer to remit a payment lower than the invoiced sum.

Once the reason for the short pay is identified, it’s essential to communicate with the customer promptly and professionally. Reach out to them to discuss the discrepancy and seek clarification on the reason for the short payment.

Be prepared to provide evidence or documentation to support your case, and be open to negotiations if necessary. In some cases, the customer may have a valid reason for the short pay, and it’s crucial to be understanding and work toward a mutually beneficial resolution.

To prevent future short pays, it’s vital to invest in improving your invoicing processes and addressing the root causes of these discrepancies. This may involve implementing automation tools for invoicing, ensuring accurate and detailed record-keeping, and establishing clear billing policies and procedures.

By maintaining strong communication with your customers and investing in the right tools and processes, you can minimize the occurrence of short pay and maintain healthy business relationships.

Lastly, track and monitor short pays over time to identify patterns and trends that can help you further optimize your invoicing process. This will enable you to address any recurring issues proactively and maintain a better understanding of your customer’s needs and expectations, ultimately leading to improved cash flow and customer satisfaction.

Dispute Management vs Deduction Management in Resolving Short Paid Invoices

Deduction management and dispute management are two distinct but interrelated processes that businesses use to handle short pays, which occur when customers pay less than the invoiced amount. Both processes involve resolving discrepancies between invoiced amounts and received payments, but they address different types of issues.

Deduction management focuses on addressing legitimate deductions that customers make from their payments, such as discounts, allowances, or promotional adjustments. These deductions are typically agreed upon between the business and the customer and are intended to incentivize the customer to meet specific goals or criteria.

In deduction management, the primary objective is to ensure that the deductions are valid, accurately applied, and properly documented to maintain accurate financial records and minimize revenue leakage.

Conversely, dispute management addresses instances where customers issue short payments due to perceived mistakes, inconsistencies, or differences in the invoicing process. These disputes can stem from a range of problems, including billing errors, pricing variances, or concerns regarding the quality or delivery of goods and services.

Dispute management emphasizes determining the underlying cause of the disagreement, addressing the problem through transparent communication and negotiation with the customer, and introducing corrective actions to avert similar disputes in the future.

Both deduction and dispute management are essential elements of a successful short-pay resolution approach. Businesses ought to focus on optimizing these processes to preserve a robust cash flow, ensure customer satisfaction, and promote operational effectiveness.

Best Practices to Reduce Short Payments

  • Accurate invoicing: Ensure that all invoices are accurate, complete, and free of errors, including correct pricing, quantities, product descriptions, and customer information, to minimize disputes.
  • Clear payment terms: Establish and communicate transparent payment terms and conditions, including payment deadlines, early payment discounts, and penalties for late payment.
  • Prompt invoicing: Issue invoices as soon as possible after the delivery of goods or services to reduce the likelihood of payment disputes and maintain a consistent cash flow.
  • Consistent formatting: Use a consistent invoice format that is easy to read and understand, with all necessary information clearly presented, to avoid confusion and reduce the risk of short payments.

    Keeping the format of your invoice consistent will be challenging if you’re using more than one source of truth. Centralizing your invoice generation in a digital invoicing system such as Peakflo will unify the format of your invoice and provide transparency at scale.
Invoice creation
  • Invoice confirmation: Ensure the customer has received the invoice and has all the required information to process the payment.
  • Regular follow-ups: Send constant reminders and touch base with customers prior to payment due dates, confirming their awareness of payment responsibilities and addressing any inquiries or concerns they might have.

    If following up on customers takes a lot of your time, consider automating payment reminders. Our reminders support multi-channel triggers (WhatsApp, email, SMS) and are easily customizable based on the escalation matrix so you can reach customers and get paid faster.
Email reminder Peakflo
  • Efficient dispute resolutions: Develop a structured process for addressing and resolving disputes quickly and fairly, minimizing the impact on cash flow and customer relationships.

    Companies often are blocked from resolving disputes as it’s difficult to keep businesses and vendors aligned on an invoice. Peakflo offers an all-in-one portal where vendors can see an overview of their invoices, make payments, and raise disputes. This way, solve any issues efficiently without hurting your invoicing cycle.
Raise a dispute in Peakflo
  • Monitor customer payment patterns: Keep track of individual customer payment habits to identify trends and address potential short payment issues before they become problematic.

    Most companies, however, do not have enough insights into their customers’ payment behavior due to the lack of documentation. Peakflo offers real-time customer tracking reports with AI predictions to help you keep a tab on the outstanding invoices on a customer level and their payment behavior so you can improve your collections strategy.
Customer status tracking report in Peakflo's accounts receivable reports
  • Maintain open communications: Foster open communication and trust with your customers, enabling you to address potential short payment incidents more effectively and maintain strong business relationships.
  • Automate invoicing processes: Implement automation tools and software to streamline invoicing, minimize human errors, and ensure consistency and accuracy in billing information.

Whether you’re dealing with short pay or other invoice issues, it’s time to take action before any negative impact affects your business. By leveraging automation, improve your end-to-end AR management and bring profits to your operations. Try out Peakflo today!

AR CTA